Update two PICOs; separate evidence tables from recommendations
Real sources · Illustrative request · Sample version
Customer question
Hypothetical commission: a guideline group has a reusable baseline for support assessment and discharge transitions.
Which new studies enter evidence tables, and which judgments belong to the formal committee?
Check baseline permissions, search dates and suitability; preserve evidence judgments, committee views and final recommendations separately.
Update checks for two questions
| Check / stage | Chart content |
|---|---|
| PICO 1: support assessment | Check definitions, population and critical outcomes |
| PICO 2: discharge transitions | Check components, care context and harms |
| Recommendation discussion | Separate evidence from values, resources and implementation views |
Fictional PICOs. No new recommendation or certainty rating is generated; baseline suitability is assessed before commissioning.
Analysis excerpt
| Check | Finding / sample content | Use |
|---|---|---|
| Baseline reuse | An old review is not automatically reusable | Check scope, quality and permissions |
| Supplementary search | Start from explicit dates and two PICOs | Deliver new studies and evidence tables |
| Committee view | Payment cannot fix recommendation direction | Keep views distinct from evidence judgments |
Delivery manifest
| File | Format | Contents |
|---|---|---|
| Two-PICO updated evidence tables | XLSX | Studies, outcomes, source locations and judgment rationale |
| Search update and baseline check | PDF / XLSX | Permissions, baseline suitability, searches/dates and eligibility |
| Recommendation discussion materials | Benefit/harm, resource/implementation questions and view-record template |
This is an illustrative formal delivery manifest. This pack supplies an HTML report, CSV tables and a source register. Agree formal formats, quantities and scope in the quote.
Acceptance criteria
- Evidence judgments, working-group views and final recommendations are separate records. Payment cannot predetermine recommendation direction.
Sources
- NICE · Updating guideline recommendations
https://www.nice.org.uk/process/pmg20/chapter/updating-guideline-recommendations